If there were two men who solidified wrestling into a status that was beyond legendary, it was Ed Lewis & The Great Gama. One was undefeated his entire career, the other was part of a trio that shaped the bridge between actual contests in Catch Wrestling to the spectacle we know today as professional wrestling.
The history between these larger than life titans is not only unbelievable but it begged the question among the inner circle of wrestlers as to why these guys never squared off to see who is the true GOAT. With it never coming to pass, it's only speculation for reasons beyond our own consciousness and research to how good they actually were.
To start off, let's get a glimpse of Gama....Born as Ghulam Mohammad Baksh Butt in what was British India that became Pakistan. Growing up, he was already being groomed into wrestling through his family that had a high stakes in the sport of Kushti. Before he even was a teenager, he already dominated other wrestlers by his level of conditioning and outworked many experienced masters in a contest consisting of squats, push-ups, mace and club swinging. Wrestling was his life, his job and his source of fame.
The man was a beast at the peak of his career standing roughly 5'7 but weighed at best 270 lbs of pure wrath. His strength was jaw dropping to the point of being able to throw guys much taller and at times bigger than him. The amount of Bethaks (The Hindu Squat) & Dands he performed were documented as many as 5000 & 4000 each practically daily while doing runs, wrestling as many as 40 sparring partners and devouring one opponent after another in competition that lasted often less than a few minutes at a time, consistently in seconds.
The most famous wrestler he faced was a champion in his own right named Stan Zbyszko who was probably the closest wrestler outside of Gama's native India to give him a hard time but as fate would have it, As powerful and solid he was as a wrestler, he still couldn't get the Punjabi Monster down for the count. It was surreal to how this man kept up such a record for so long that what happened to guys like Gotch, Hackenshmidt and others of that era that never faced him? His record as far as history is concerned is still in tact and will mostly stay there for all time, like Cy Young's Baseball Wins Record or Joe Montana's Undefeated Record as a Quarterback in the Super Bowl.
Moving onto what many arguably say is the greatest American Wrestler of all time or should I say the greatest Catch Wrestler of all time, Ed "Strangler" Lewis.....Born as Robert Julius Fredrick in the rural towns of Wisconsin, he became a man that would shape the very foundation to what would become what we know today as Professional Wrestling. His style was considered boring to paid audiences but to the wrestlers that sparred, competed and watched him work, he was a living masterpiece of an athlete. He was also the man that would succeed Frank Gotch after his death in 1917. A dangerous Hooker by trade (meaning he could cripple opponents with submissions that tore ligaments, bones and dislocations to practically any part of the body. He didn't look like he was carved into a Greek God by any stretch of the imagination, he was built closer to a gorilla at a whopping 260 at his peak at 5'10 but what seperated him from other wrestlers was his stamina. Despite his appearance, he could outwrestle just about anybody that came across him. To such a degree that Lou Thesz (Ed's Protégé) has said that when Ed had sparring partners, using as many as 5 for 5 minutes each for hours, he would just as fresh at the end then when he started.
Mike Chapman who has written countless books on the sport of wrestling has said that even in his mind that Ed was the best period. He could beat anybody, anywhere at any length he wanted to. What truly needs to be noted is that Ed rarely if at all lost in a legitimate contest and most of his loses came from performing matches throughout the 20's and 30's. When it came down to it, he only lost because he allowed it, if he wanted to rough a guy up especially of championship caliber, Ed could do it and make his opponent work like a mule until he wore him down. His match against Joe Stecher was considered at that time and I believe since, the longest match in Catch History. They went at it for 5 1/2 hours to a draw. By the time it was all said and done, the audience was practically gone and 4 referees were exhausted (one at a time bowed out).
Because of the press and the need for action, Ed had partnered up with two other guys; Billy Sandow and Toodts Mont to form what became famously known as the "Gold Dust Trio" where they turned the slow scientific matches into a much faster paced spectacle where time limits became the it factor and inventing "show holds" meaning holds that they can put on that could get the audience riled up along with flashy moves of the time like the Drop Kick for example. Traveled around putting on cards that took them into the stratosphere of making bank. Eventually the trio separated due to conflicts of interests and having Mont being quite the backstabbing greedy businessman he was. For the record, Toodts was a capable and legit wrestler himself and Sandow (no relation to Eugene) was a smart businessman.
For Ed as time went on, although still able to go at a high level, was having health issues due to trachoma, heavy drinking and womanizing that would make Babe Ruth blush. His body began to wear down and what once was a powerful barrel chested master, became a morbidly obese of a man that could barely travel, let alone wrestle. He did live life to the fullest that's for sure and his successor in Thesz proved that with great knowledge from the true masters, wrestling will never die. The closest peers Ed had in his prime would be Ad Santel, Ray Steele and George Tragos. Look into these guys and you'll understand why the Hookers were feared men of the mat.
Now, let's get down to it, who really was the GOAT of wrestling out of these two monsters? Well, like I said, it's speculative but let's see what we can make of it. First off, their styles are completely different from one another; Gama's ability was to throw, toss and takedown opponents that had a combination of Freestyle & Greco-Roman. Ed, was a well known Submission Specialist, meaning he could tie a guy up anyway he wanted and put him in holds that were known to be illegal or crippling to a degree where he could put you in the hospital just by tearing a knee or dislocating a shoulder in several ways.
Both had a ridiculous amount of stamina from their perspective ways of conditioning and strength training as well as grappling itself. In some retrospect, Ed has more of an advantage because if it were a legit Catch Contest where submissions were allowed, Gama most likely wouldn't know how to handle him, he can't rely on his strength and cardio alone and Ed would have the ability to set him up well even if Gama thinks he's got him on the ropes so do speak. So there's that when it comes down to it.
If it were a a contest that was suited to Gama's style, I don't believe he would have that high of advantage but here's a thing that we never got into. They're 12-13 years apart in age so Gama may have an advantage due to experience of his style of the sport. Ed was a solid shooter, he had to be because it was just second to being a Hooker and if a Hooker couldn't go with a Shooter, it would be embarrassing and that wrestler may get blacklisted because Hookers were meant to be the better wrestler. So in a shoot, Gama would have somewhat of a piece ahead of Ed but I only say that because the contest would go a lot longer than Gama would be used to. Sure he can go for hours if he wanted to but if you look into his competitive history, his matches never went longer than 15 minutes at best I believe. Ed can work a guy in any way he wanted so toe to toe, he would give Gama a run for his money and test his durability.
Safe to say in some aspects, they're pretty even in terms of being able to go at it and give each a hard fought match. I would say in most cases, it would be a draw but if it came down to submissions, Ed would have Gama within an ankle lock or Double Wrist Lock within 20-30 minutes tops. If submissions weren't allowed and based on age and experience, Gama is the victor but not by much, he would have to work his ass off to get Ed down or thrown. I could see a match of that caliber go at best 3 hours before Gama had him down. There would be a chain of moves and because of Ed's Defensive abilities, he would have Gama making changes that he could adapt to but not easy to conjure up.
That's really my take on it considering their history and their impact on the sport. No bias, no rage baiting or anything. Just a pure observation of their legend as wrestlers and where that match might have stood on the premise of their respective status. I can't really pick who could really win but from the observations I made above, I think I analyzed it pretty well. Hope you enjoyed this piece and let me know in the comments what you think or leave a comment on social media after I post it. Be amazingly awesome and let's keep Wrestling History in our minds and share it.
