There was an article I read a few days ago that was a little different to read but it's partially not that surprising. A High School football coach from Texas (the Mecca of Football) was suspended and investigated for putting his players through a Push-Up challenge as a punishment and the challenge was to do 300-400 Push-Ups within an hour. 8 boys were hospitalized because of it.
Now whether this is just another story that could be fabricated who really knows and I do see both sides to the issue but let's stick to the big thing here. Many kids today aren't in the shape this challenge calls for and yes it can be a tough challenge but it's not impossible to do WITH THE RIGHT WAY TO TRAIN FOR IT!!! Do I think these boys are pussies for being put in the hospital? Hell no, I do sympathize with them and hope they get back on their feet soon. The trouble I have is, yes these boys should train to be able to do that however, since the coach is very old school from what I read, he pushed them to the extent where their bodies didn't have the capacity to withstand that amount of stress. I believe in a kid training for any sport to prepare themselves for whatever challenge comes to them and they weren't prepared.
Those boys should not be in football if they can't put themselves through that hard training and it's not entirely their fault, the parents should've helped them prepare for that. I'll give you an example: When I was in high school, I was in nowhere even close to the shape I'm in now and I went out for Shot Put & Discus and Wrestling. The Shot Put was purely using Weight Training but even with that, I wasn't that good and didn't need a ton of conditioning but I also had no preparation to handle injuries and I got elbow and shoulder issues because of that. The wrestling was the hardest and if I hadn't gotten hurt from a bad knee and nearly breaking my wrists, I would've kept up with it as best as I could. We did push-ups, squats, wall sits, drills, sprints up stairs, suicide runs before, during and after sparring. It's brutal but I sure as hell never went to the hospital.
One of these boys was reported to have a disease that was prone to kidney failure and that was what got me because for one, the coach had to have known this otherwise he wouldn't have let that kid on the team and two, the parent(s) pushed that kid most likely or the boy wanted to be on the team so bad that the parents couldn't let go of his ambition and let him do it. That kid needed help. I understand also the need to want to prove yourself even at the risk of one's own health. It's human nature.
These days, many boys have no conditioning or structure or discipline because it's easier to just chill, play video games and not play outside so much since many parents today are either way uninvolved or too involved that it can screw up a kid's future. I've been around kids my whole life and have observed many parents in my lifetime and can't wait to be a father one of these days but if I were a parent, I would challenge my kids to help prepare them so they can handle certain things that will be thrown at them and physical fitness is definitely one of them. Trust me, I didn't really get fit until I was 21 years old and was never a fit kid that could do countless push-ups and sprint till my legs were ready to fall off. Yeah I played outside and all that but I didn't have a coach or a person to teach me how to condition my body or better yet gave me an interesting concept to help me. P.E helped to a small degree but I was never in decent shape until after I was in high school.
Now that we got all that out of the way, let's play a math game here. 300-400 Push-Ups in an hour is tough but not impossible if you look at the math from a certain point of view. These boys were probably pushed to doing consecutive reps their bodies couldn't handle and they ended up having piss that was darkened and had injured their shoulders and arms. Now if either they, or the coach for that matter, taught or learned the math that shows how it is reasonable and applicable to handle that many reps in that span of time, none of this would've ever happened. I get the punishment and disciplining the kid, I'm not faulting that, kids need a kick in the ass every now and then but not to the point where Life and Death is creeping up at a faster rate than Usain Bolt's 100 meter sprints.
If a person can do 20 Reps in a span of a minute (which is roughly 3 seconds per rep), it is very possible to do 300 within less time and have a small increment of rest before the next minute. Apparently there wasn't much time to rest according to the coach and no water breaks until they finished (that's a bit of an issue in itself since this took place in fucking Texas where high heatwaves are normal). At that pace, the boys most likely couldn't do that and even tried to do more than that and paid the price for it. If they did 5-7 reps per minute, get the reps in and rested until the time changed and repeated that for the hour, they could've easily done 300-420 reps in that time.
5 Reps (at a pace of 2-3 seconds per rep) is still 10-15 seconds with a max of 45 seconds of rest time....5 Reps = 1 minute, 1 hour is 60 minutes, 5x60 is 300. Now if they attempted to do the 400 in that time frame which they can do 6-7 push-ups per minute (pace of 2-3 seconds per rep) is still 12-18 seconds for 6 reps and 14-21 seconds for 7, still gives them the rest period of let's say 35-40 seconds till the time changed. 6 Reps = 1 minute, in the span of an hour that's 6x60 is 360 reps. For 7 Reps = 1 minute, in that hour 7x60 is 420 reps. These numbers would've been very easy to shoot for to complete 300-400 in that span of time. Isn't math fun? The parents never saw this (neither did the coach apparently) and all the parents saw was how horrible to put the boys through that many because it's such a huge number (in reality it isn't).
Like I said, I see both sides to the issue and the coach did his best at punishing and disciplining, it just could've gone a different way and both the coach and those players would've been satisfied (even though those kids would've been pissed off at the guy anyway since hello teenage boys). On one hand, if a kid can't handle the stress of the training, he shouldn't be in a sport because sports are hard and if you want to be good at them, you need to train accordingly and sometimes that means taking it to the limit (without suffering injuries of course) in the training process, injuries happen, there's no getting around that but there are ways to limit it. You can't expect a kid to be just thrown on a team and expect it to be just sunshine and rainbows and not feel the wrath of exhaustion or playing a little hurt. There's going to be an injury somewhere on the field but it shouldn't be as frequent in practice.
All in all, I never want to see a kid hurt in a sport or pushed to the point where he/she ends up in the ER over something that could've been prevented with progressive training instead of pushing so damn hard the body couldn't handle it in the first place. There needs to be balance which many times is thrown off but can be done in most cases because each kid is different and handles physical and mental stress differently. It is a small complex issue but again kids today don't have the same drive as others did even 20 years ago. Much has changed, not always for the better but we can do great things and get fit if we applied it to the individual's needs and not try to make people do the same thing the same way for everyone involved, it's not going to work that way the majority of the time.
Be safe, get strong/conditioned and if you have a kid going out for a sport of any kind, prepare him/her beforehand in small increments so they can be ready to tackle the challenges ahead and learn how to make the most of what's possible. Keep being amazingly awesome.
